Authors: Gale F. Hoffnagle, CCM, QEP | January 5, 2024
On October 23, 2023, the US EPA proposed changes to the “Guideline on Air Quality Models” and the US EPA model AERMOD. The agency additionally proposed a new guidance document (a separate document) entitled “Guidance on Developing Background Concentrations for use in Modeling Demonstrations”. This Guidance has implications for permitting, particularly for sources of PM2.5 (particulate matter less than 2.5 microns in size) and precursors of PM2.5 (sulfur oxides (SOx or SO2) and nitrogen oxides (NOx)) and sources of nitrogen oxides alone.
Importance of Background Concentrations
US EPA is preparing to reduce the National Ambient Air Quality Standard (NAAQS) for PM2.5 from 12 micrograms per cubic meter to as low as 8 or 9 micrograms per cubic meter. Since background concentrations make up the majority of the PM2.5 currently measured in the ambient air, many more areas of the country will be designated as non-attainment, thus subjecting new and modified sources in those areas to much more difficult permitting issues.
For sources in attainment areas, the determination of background concentrations is crucial because current measured background concentrations will be much closer to the NAAQS allowable levels. This will lead to much smaller or non-existent room for new sources of PM2.5 (either direct emissions or emissions from chemical reactions of SOx or NOx after release to the atmosphere). This means that new facilities and modifications to existing facilities will be much more difficult to permit.
Current Use of Monitoring Data
If there is a monitor in a given location which can be deemed representative of background concentrations, current practice is to use that data to represent the background concentration. The measured background concentration is added to the modeled results for the new source to determine compliance with the NAAQS. In most case the new source contributes only a small percentage (1 or 2 micrograms per cubic meter) and the background is much greater than the source contribution.
What the New Guidance Requires
The proposed Guidance requires a four-step process to set a background concentration:
- Define the scope of the study including the NAAQS, the averaging period, the modeling domain and the dispersion environment.
- Find the relevant ambient monitoring data, the available emissions data for all sources which might affect the background concentrations and previous modeling in the area for the pollutant in question.
- Determine the representativeness of ambient monitoring data if available. The Guidance requires a visual comparison of locations of the monitor regarding emitting sources, the proposed source, terrain and meteorology. This requires a qualified individual to conduct an on-site evaluation of the project area and the monitoring site. The result of this requirement may force many sources to conduct their own site-specific ambient monitoring prior to permitting. This might require up to one years’ worth of monitoring.
- Evaluate emission sources that might not be represented in the monitored data (for instance newer or permitted but not built sources), perform additional quantitative assessment to assess the impact of other sources and, finally, fully document justification for any decisions made. The implication is that many situations will require that all identifiable sources will need to be modeled resulting in a lot more effort.
Implications for Project Permitting
As can be imagined, these changes will add significant effort to the front end of any permitting and/or modeling project. The procedure also leads to the expectation that many more sources will have to be included in the model than is currently the case.
Methods that are not condoned by the Guidance but have been used previously are:
- Use of the gradient (fall off with distance) of a source’s concentrations to eliminate it from the modeling for background.
- Use of the hourly monitored data from a monitor designated to be the background concentration for that hour or day.
EPA states that the motivation for this Guidance is due to inconsistency in previous PSD demonstrations and the Guideline lacked definition. No examples or rigorous evaluation of that claim was given, but it is clear that modeling for PM2.5 and the 1-hour average NAAQS for SO2 and NO2, will be significantly more complicated and expensive under this new Guidance.
Next Steps
The comment period on the Guidelines and Guidance closed on December 23, 2023. Promulgation expected by summer.
TRC is available to support your air compliance and permitting needs by offering expert in-house resources to perform:
- Ambient Monitor Siting Evaluation
- Ambient Monitor Deployment, Operation and Maintenance
- Air Dispersion Modeling
- Permitting
- Performance Testing
- Expert Testimony and Agency Negotiation
Embrace The Shift
Partner With TRC’s Tested Practitioners
Sharing Our Perspectives
Our practitioners share their insights and perspectives on the trends and challenges shaping the market.
PM2.5 Annual NAAQS Revised
May 7, 2024
The U.S. EPA issued a final rule based on its reconsideration of its 2020 decision to retain the primary and secondary National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) for particulate matter (PM) without revision.
EPA Issues Regulations for Oil and Natural Gas Sector Tank Emissions
April 30, 2024
Storage Vessel or Tank Battery Operators Must Reduce Emissions by 95%.
EPA Proposes Rules for IRA-mandated Waste Emissions Charge for Methane
February 6, 2024
EPA proposed rules to implement the Waste Emissions Charge (WEC) program for facilities that exceed a waste emissions threshold
EPA Proposes New Guidance on Air Quality Analysis for Permits
January 5, 2024
On October 23, 2023, the US EPA proposed changes to the Guideline on Air Quality Models and the US EPA model AERMOD
Modeling of Fogging and Icing Events
December 14, 2023
In recent years, various agencies across the country have become committed to understanding the impacts of fog generated by cooling systems. At first glance, fog created by cooling towers may not appear to be a significant problem, however, it can have adverse effects on the public. Fog can impair visibility for people driving on roads and if temperatures are below freezing, fog can cause the formation of rime ice on surfaces. To understand the consequences of fog created by these cooling systems, experts have devised advanced modeling techniques.
EPA Proposes Regulation of Green House Gas Emissions
July 10, 2023
This article highlights the EPA’s proposed rules to regulate greenhouse gas emissions from power plants and the potential impact on new and existing fossil fuel-fired facilities.
TRC Acquires United Sciences Testing, Inc., Expanding Air Management Capabilities
February 23, 2022
TRC Companies (“TRC”), announced the expansion of its Air Management capabilities with the acquisition of United Sciences Testing, Inc. (USTI), who provides emissions testing services to utility and industrial clients within the Great Lakes and Midwest regions of the US.
EPA Adds First New Hazardous Air Pollutant Since 1990
January 14, 2022
EPA finalized a rule to add 1-bromopropane to the federal list of hazardous air pollutants (HAPs) on December 22, 2022.
Air Emissions Permitting: What Analytical Laboratories Need to Know About Compliance
December 18, 2021
The independent testing of liquid and solid samples is a critical way that businesses demonstrate regulatory compliance. The laboratories that perform these analyses are also subject to environmental rules and should closely track their operations to ensure they are meeting compliance obligations.
EPA Proposes Changes to Methane Control at Petroleum Operations
November 10, 2021
New Source Performance Standard for Methane Control at Petroleum Operations in 2022
PFAS Air Emissions Standards and Trends for Summer 2021
August 17, 2021
Environmental impacts of PFAS in ambient air leads to states implementing PFAS air-related thresholds.
Managing EHS & ESG Risks Through Integrated Systems Today and Beyond
July 22, 2021
It has been more than 50 years since the development and establishment of the federal Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the federal Occupational Safety & Health Administration (OSHA) which were formed to protect our environment and workplaces across the United States. Significant laws, policies and regulations followed to establish the “regulatory programs” that all applicable businesses and entities must address and meet to ensure these compliance-driven legislative programs would create a foundation to protect our society.
EPA Ramps Up Inspections and Enforcement Actions
May 14, 2021
EPA’s acting enforcement chief, Larry Starfield, directs agents to ramp up inspections in communities known to be afflicted by pollution
South Coast Air Quality Management District Rule 2305: Warehouse Indirect Source Rule
April 7, 2021
The rule is intended to reduce local and regional emissions of NOx and diesel particulate matter (PM).
EPA Clean Air Act Rulemaking Announced December 2020
December 31, 2020
EPA announces Clean Air Act Rulemaking in the final month of the current administration and indicates more could be announced before the new administration comes into office.
New Jersey’s Landmark Environmental Justice Law
November 24, 2020
Many facilities require air quality measurement testing programs to verify compliance with regulatory permits, assess new air pollution control equipment performance and certify the continuous emission monitoring (CEM) equipment associated with the production processes. Proper, accurate, efficient and timely execution of compliance test programs reduces costs while providing defensible data that are representative of source emissions. In the absence of proper planning, important details can be overlooked, resulting in last minute changes that are costly with the potential to delay the test program. Proper planning, coupled with informed oversight, ensures the test program is performed successfully, in full accordance with appropriate methods and agency coordination and supported by the full complement of required measurement and process data. This webinar, tailored to meet the needs of facilities in Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Michigan, Missouri and Wisconsin, shares best practices and outlines key considerations to equip participants with the skills to manage air quality measurement programs that achieve technically-sound results and fully support the compliance and operational objectives of all types of facilities. Topics discussed by TRC’s Dan Grabowski and Doug Ryan include: A systematic approach to stack test planning and oversight General notification and reporting requirements EPA’s Electronic Reporting Tool (ERT) Update on EPA’s Stationary Source Audit Program (SSAP)
EPA Finalizes Reversal of “Once In Always In” Air Pollution Policy
November 18, 2020
On October 1, 2020, the EPA finalized a ruling that no longer enforces the “once in, always in” air emissions policy.
TRC Awarded a Yahara WINS Grant
August 28, 2020
TRC was recently awarded a Yahara WINS grant to develop a pilot scale simple aeration method for removing phosphorous from the discharge of manure digesters. The grant application was developed and submitted by: Bob Stanforth, Alyssa Sellwood, Mike Ursin, Ted O’Connell, Ken Quinn, and John Rice, who are members of multiple TRC CORE teams.
New York State Finalizes Emission Limits for Power Generators
January 21, 2020
On January 16, 2020, the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC) finalized a rulemaking limiting nitrogen oxide (NOx) emissions from existing simple cycle and regenerative peaking combustion turbines with a nameplate capacity of 15 megawatts (MW) or greater during the ozone season (May 1 – October 31).
EPA Signs New Rule Affecting Air Emissions from Stationary Combustion Turbines
September 16, 2024
EPA finalized the residual risk and technology review (RTR) of the National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants (NESHAP) for Stationary Combustion Turbines.
EPA Proposes New Guidance on Air Quality Analysis for Permits
January 5, 2024
On October 23, 2023, the US EPA proposed changes to the Guideline on Air Quality Models and the US EPA model AERMOD
Modeling of Fogging and Icing Events
December 14, 2023
In recent years, various agencies across the country have become committed to understanding the impacts of fog generated by cooling systems. At first glance, fog created by cooling towers may not appear to be a significant problem, however, it can have adverse effects on the public. Fog can impair visibility for people driving on roads and if temperatures are below freezing, fog can cause the formation of rime ice on surfaces. To understand the consequences of fog created by these cooling systems, experts have devised advanced modeling techniques.
EPA Issues Information Collection Request for Plywood and Composite Wood Products Source Operators
March 17, 2022
EPA issued an Information Collection Request (ICR) to develop new emission standards for inclusion in the Plywood and Composite Wood Products (PCWP) National Emissions Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants (NESHAP).
EPA Lifts Stay of Standards for New Lean Premix and Diffusion Flame Gas-fired Combustion Turbines
March 14, 2022
The EPA Administration signed a notice to finalize amendments to the National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants (NESHAP) for Stationary Combustion Turbines
TRC Acquires United Sciences Testing, Inc., Expanding Air Management Capabilities
February 23, 2022
TRC Companies (“TRC”), announced the expansion of its Air Management capabilities with the acquisition of United Sciences Testing, Inc. (USTI), who provides emissions testing services to utility and industrial clients within the Great Lakes and Midwest regions of the US.
Air Emissions Permitting: What Analytical Laboratories Need to Know About Compliance
December 18, 2021
The independent testing of liquid and solid samples is a critical way that businesses demonstrate regulatory compliance. The laboratories that perform these analyses are also subject to environmental rules and should closely track their operations to ensure they are meeting compliance obligations.
EPA Proposes Changes to Methane Control at Petroleum Operations
November 10, 2021
New Source Performance Standard for Methane Control at Petroleum Operations in 2022
PFAS Air Emissions Standards and Trends for Summer 2021
August 17, 2021
Environmental impacts of PFAS in ambient air leads to states implementing PFAS air-related thresholds.
Managing EHS & ESG Risks Through Integrated Systems Today and Beyond
July 22, 2021
It has been more than 50 years since the development and establishment of the federal Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the federal Occupational Safety & Health Administration (OSHA) which were formed to protect our environment and workplaces across the United States. Significant laws, policies and regulations followed to establish the “regulatory programs” that all applicable businesses and entities must address and meet to ensure these compliance-driven legislative programs would create a foundation to protect our society.
EPA Proposes New Emissions Limits for Combustion Turbines
May 22, 2021
After 15 years of legal limbo, combustion turbines could be facing new emissions standards under a proposal introduced by the EPA.
EPA Ramps Up Inspections and Enforcement Actions
May 14, 2021
EPA’s acting enforcement chief, Larry Starfield, directs agents to ramp up inspections in communities known to be afflicted by pollution
South Coast Air Quality Management District Rule 2305: Warehouse Indirect Source Rule
April 7, 2021
The rule is intended to reduce local and regional emissions of NOx and diesel particulate matter (PM).
EPA Finalizes Reversal of “Once In Always In” Air Pollution Policy
November 18, 2020
On October 1, 2020, the EPA finalized a ruling that no longer enforces the “once in, always in” air emissions policy.
TRC Awarded a Yahara WINS Grant
August 28, 2020
TRC was recently awarded a Yahara WINS grant to develop a pilot scale simple aeration method for removing phosphorous from the discharge of manure digesters. The grant application was developed and submitted by: Bob Stanforth, Alyssa Sellwood, Mike Ursin, Ted O’Connell, Ken Quinn, and John Rice, who are members of multiple TRC CORE teams.
New York State Finalizes Emission Limits for Power Generators
January 21, 2020
On January 16, 2020, the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC) finalized a rulemaking limiting nitrogen oxide (NOx) emissions from existing simple cycle and regenerative peaking combustion turbines with a nameplate capacity of 15 megawatts (MW) or greater during the ozone season (May 1 – October 31).
New York State Proposes Emissions Limits for Power Generators
March 22, 2019
On February 27, 2019, the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC) released a proposed rulemaking limiting nitrogen oxide (NOx) emissions from existing simple cycle and regenerative peaking combustion turbines with a nameplate capacity of 15 megawatts (MW) or greater during the ozone season (May 1 – October 31).
Gale Hoffnagle
Gale F. Hoffnagle, CCM, QEP is a Senior Vice President and technical Director in the Air Quality Consulting Practice. He has 52 years of consulting experience and 38 years of service to TRC. He advised clients on the Clean Air Act amendments of 1977 and 1990. Contact Gale at GHoffnagle@trccompanies.com.